Diet v Exercise

Diet v Exercise

They are both important, obviously. But when you’re looking to accomplish something specific, which one weighs more heavily? In the artcile Diet v. Exercise: The Smackdown, Women’s Health writer Ellen Page breaks it down…and I’m recappin’ it in case you aren’t the article readin’ type! :)

What are you trying to achieve?

If you said weight loss: diet wins. You can easily (with self-control) eliminate 500 calories from your diet but to burn 500 calories at the gym? That takes far more work. So here, you diet is key to losing weight. Exercise (followed by diet) is key to keeping the weight off.

If you said to be more energized: exercise wins. When we exercise, our brain sends all kinds of good neurotransmitters out (like norepinephrine) which causes an energy boost. You know what else I think? I think it causes a happiness boost, too :)

If you said to prevent diabetes: exercise wins. A lot of people think it’s all about diet but exercise is actually important here. My mom has diabetes so I know if I don’t take care of myself, I could be at risk. Page says: “Achieving a healthy weight through diet and exercise is the strongest defense against the disease, but physical activity has a slight edge. Active muscles gobble up glucose from the blood for fuel, which helps keep blood-sugar levels stable.” Good to know!

If you said improving your mood: exercise wins. Did you know that a 20-minute workout can be enough to boost your mood for 12 hours? Man, if working out alone doesn’t provide enough benefits this added bonus really makes it even better! I need to exercise for like, 5 hours after work then :)

I was surprised to find out diet isn’t the leading factor in preventing diabetes but then again, it does seem like getting exercise is key to overcoming a lot of mental barriers.

Hope everyone has a wonderful Thursday!

If you enjoyed this article, you might also like...

  1. Diet Pills are a Tool to Health?
  2. Famous Exercise Inspiration!
  3. Goals.
  4. The Challenge
  5. Things to Look for on Food Labels
This entry was posted in Health and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3SIIM3YLZY2JCJ65NOELY5VVSE sera0014

    Why can’t I just eat all I want & be thin & healthy please?! Perfect world…

  • Stephanie

    I think exercise is the cure all for most things, but agree that diet is the place to start for weight loss, I guess more specifically- portion control!rn

  • http://www.5krae.blogspot.com Rae

    When I set my goal and started to lose weight I definitely cut out junk and things I didn’t need and I exercised almost daily. I love to exercise. Now that I reached my goal weight, I exercise to maintain my weight and for the energy part…I have 3 kids to keep up with. :)

  • Liz @ lizrunsdc

    I definitely would agree from my personal experience that diet contributes more to weight loss/management, but exercise is so much easier for me!

  • http://primalkiwi.wordpress.com/ Kate

    I’m not sure about diabetes being controlled more by exercise. Sure, exercise uses glucose, but after exercise your body craves foods high in carbohydrates to replenish the glycogen stores. Ever noticed how you don’t crave something fatty after exercise and are more likely to eat a sandwich or piece of fruit? Bread, pasta, fruit etc. = carbohydrates which break down into simple sugars in the stomach. What happens with your diabetes when you give in to that desire and flood your blood stream with carbs aka sugar…?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=503990714 Heather Wilson

    I agree that a healthy diet & portion control is more important for overall weight loss, but I don’t see the point in forgoing exercise. When I reach my goal weight I not only want to be “thin” but I want to be fit and look fit. I’ve seen women lose lots of weight without exercising at all and though they do end up thin, they look flabby to me and that’s not what I want, so for my goals exercise and diet go hand in hand.

  • http://www.shelbystidham.com Shelby Stidham

    And have Ryan Reynolds be your maid?

  • http://www.shelbystidham.com Shelby Stidham

    I agree–being fit is a huge part of weight loss and the overall outcome. I am thinking what this article meant was the initial weight loss takes a lot of diet control.

  • http://www.shelbystidham.com Shelby Stidham

    I agree with you–it seems like exercise makes soo much better! And yep–portion control is key. I still struggle with it everyday!

blog comments powered by Disqus